Skip to content
Nail salons
Color by Coley
Color by Coley

Color by Coley

Nail salon in Pickerington, OH

The business is run by Coley, who works as a nail technician, esthetician, makeup artist and face painter. Most services are by appointment, and clients can book online or text for the best availability. Walk-ins are welcome for select services.

Read more

About

The business is run by Coley, who works as a nail technician, esthetician, makeup artist and face painter. Most services are by appointment, and clients can book online or text for the best availability. Walk-ins are welcome for select services.

The nail menu covers natural-nail manicures and pedicures in several levels, including options for children ages 10 and under and for men, along with acrylic and PolyGel sculpted sets, soak-offs and fills. The business uses organic and cruelty-free products and vegan polishes, and offers less-toxic, fume-free enhancements; its PolyGel is scentless.

Facials are customized to each client's skin type, needs and goals, from a signature facial to a deluxe facial with two rounds of deep cleansing, a custom mask and extractions or dermaplaning on request. A microdermabrasion facial is described by the business as able to improve the look of sun damage, wrinkles, fine lines, age spots and acne scarring. Massage options run from a short mini massage to full-body and deluxe sessions, and waxing is offered for face and body using a soft wax.

Event services include airbrush makeup, bridal makeup and updo trials, special occasion hair, prom or homecoming makeup, and one-on-one makeup lessons. Face painting is offered for parties, corporate events and birthdays, with travel to Columbus, Zanesville, Delaware and Dayton; on-location services carry a $100 travel fee. Event clients can also be referred to other entertainers such as balloon twisters and magicians, and groups can be booked as a package.

Cancellations made at least 24 hours ahead avoid a fee, while later cancellations are charged half the appointment price and a no-call, no-show is charged in full. Credit card payments carry a 3.5% plus $0.20 service charge, and cash, Google Pay, Zelle, Venmo and Cash App avoid it; PayPal and Apple Pay are not accepted. New clients referred by an existing client receive $10 off their first visit.

Each service is shaped around the client's skin, needs and goals, with a focus on comfort and a relaxed experience.

Specials & promotions

  • Save more when you book multiple services together

    On their website as of Oct 31, 2026 · Where we saw it

  • $10 off first visit for a friend you refer

    All offers must be mentioned at check out.

    On their website as of Oct 31, 2026 · Where we saw it

  • 10% off your next visit after referring a new client

    All offers must be mentioned at check out.

    On their website as of Oct 31, 2026 · Where we saw it

Services

Final prices may vary.

Extras that can be added to nail services, such as a gel base, a deluxe add-on, gel polish, nail correction for a broken nail, and hand-painted nail art.

  • Add On Structure Gel Base $5
  • Blow-dry Style Add On $25
  • Nail Correction $5
  • Plump Add-on $5
  • Deluxe Add On $10
  • Gel Polish Add On $10
  • Nail Art Add On Price at booking

Scalp-focused sessions ranging from a 45-minute express experience to a 2-hour signature restore with a facial and high frequency comb, plus an optional blow-dry style.

  • Add On Blow-dry Style $25
  • Express Experience $90
  • 2 Hr Essential Elements Restore $220
  • 2 Hr Essential Elements Restore Signature Experience $220

Strip lash application and demi-permanent brow tinting.

  • Strip Lash Application $19
  • Brow Tint $21

Styled hair, makeup trials, a one-on-one makeup lesson, prom and homecoming makeup, airbrush makeup, updos and Halloween or theatrical makeup.

  • Styled Hair (Short) $46
  • Makeup Trial $55
  • Makeup Lesson $59
  • Styled Hair (Long) $59
  • Prom/Homecoming Makeup $65
  • Special Occasion Hair Updo (Short) $65
  • Airbrush Makeup $85
  • Special Occasion Hair Updo (Long) $85
  • Halloween / Theatrical Makeup Price at booking

Full-body massage options, from a 30-minute mini massage to a deluxe session of about 90 minutes.

  • Mini Massage $50
  • Signature Full Body Massage $90
  • Deluxe Massage $130
  • SignatureMassage $85
  • Relaxation Massage Price at booking

Acrylic and PolyGel sculpted full sets, fills and balances, and soak-offs for acrylic and dip nails.

  • Acrylic or Dip Nails Soak Off $50
  • Acrylic Balance / Fill $52
  • Polygel Sculpted Balance / Fill $69
  • Acrylic Full Set $72
  • Polygel Sculpted Full Set $83
  • Acrylic Balance $52
  • PolyGel Sculpt Balance / Fill $69
  • PolyGel Sculpt Full Set $79

Manicures and pedicures for hands and feet, including children's, men's, express, signature and deluxe options, plus gel polish and nail art.

  • Child Manicure (10 and under) $20
  • Gel Soak Off (Removal) $20
  • Award Winning Naked Manicure $25
  • Express Manicure $25
  • Child Pedicure (10 and under) $30
  • Naked Manicure Gelie Cure $31
  • Signature Manicure $39
  • Express Pedicure $40
  • Men's Manicure $45
  • Deluxe Manicure $49
  • Gel Manicure $49
  • Gel Manicure (with soak off) $49
  • Signature Pedicure $52
  • Men's Pedicure $57
  • Deluxe Pedicure $62
  • Polish Change Price at booking
  • Add-on Nail Art $5–$59
  • Add-on Gel Polish / Luxe $10

Customized facials, a microdermabrasion facial, body treatments and a relaxation massage.

  • Signature Facial $80
  • Deluxe Facial $95
  • Microdermabrasion Rejuvenating Facial $100
  • Luxury Body Treatment $250
  • Mini Facial Price at booking
  • Luxe Body Treatment $199

Face and body waxing with soft wax, from eyebrows and lip to bikini, half leg and full leg.

  • Chin $14
  • Upper Lip $14
  • Eyebrows $19
  • Under Arm $24
  • Half Leg $42
  • Full Face (Brows, Lip, Chin) $45
  • Eyebrow $18
  • Bikini $38
  • Full Face $45
  • Full Leg $68
  • Bridal Makeup Trial $55
  • Bride Hair Trial - Updo $55
  • Special Occasion Hair (short) $65
  • Airbrush Make-up Application $85
  • Special Occasion Hair (long) $85
  • Travel Fee $100
  • Halloween Makeup (2 hour design) $219

Photos

  • Client receiving a facial treatment, black and white
  • Four-panel gold glitter eyeshadow and liner makeup result
  • Child with pink heart face painting
  • Bride with curled half-up hairstyle and flowers
  • Short nude gel nails with black dot and stripe designs
  • Silver shimmer eyeshadow with winged liner and plum lip
  • Matte black and holographic nails with black line art
  • Short nails with cat-eye finish and red lip graphics
  • Grey gel nails with glitter accents and rhinestone details
  • Holographic glitter nails in pastel shades
  • Woman with brows, eyeliner and lip color
  • Red and gold glitter nails with painted roses

Meet the team

Team members listed on their website. Individual roles, credentials, and current employment have not been independently verified.colorbycoley.com (opens in a new tab)

Highlights
  • Gelie Cure nail restoration for nails after gel, acrylic, PolyGel or dip
  • Hand-painted nail art added to any manicure or pedicure
  • Airbrush makeup for events, with moisturizer, primer and setting spray included
  • Head spa menu with a 2-hour Essential Elements Restore Signature Experience
  • Face painting for events, traveling to several nearby cities
  • Organic, cruelty-free products and vegan nail polishes
Good for
  • children ages 10 and under
  • bridal and event clients
  • on-location parties and events
  • clients restoring natural nails after enhancements
  • walk-ins for select services
  • men's manicures and pedicures
  • clients wanting a longer, relaxed appointment
Treats
  • sun damage
  • fine lines and wrinkles
  • age spots
  • acne scarring
  • damaged or discolored nails
  • unwanted hair
  • brow shaping
  • scalp care
Techniques
  • Gelie Cure nail restoration
  • airbrush makeup
  • PolyGel sculpting
  • acrylic nails
  • dip soak-off
  • hand-painted nail art
  • microdermabrasion
  • dermaplaning
  • extractions
  • soft wax

Products & treatments

  • Organic and cruelty-free products
  • Vegan nail polishes
  • Scentless PolyGel
  • Gelie Cure restoration system

Similar salons nearby

Book online Call